Columns
Residents' Association Image

Residents' Association

An election is upon us!
Read more >>

Business in Southbank Image

Business in Southbank

Giving back in more ways than one
Read more >>

St Johns Southgate Image

St Johns Southgate

The worst thing to lose and the best thing to have
Read more >>

Owners Corporation Law Image

Owners Corporation Law

Bill fails to protect residents
Read more >>

Montague Community Alliance Image

Montague Community Alliance

Hello … Hi … Hi … Over here … What about us? YES, US!
Read more >>

Metro Tunnel

Anzac Station roof construction underway
Read more >>

Federal Politics Image

Federal Politics

Why Magnitsky Act is important for Australia
Read more >>

We Live Here Image

We Live Here

More support for Owners’ Corporations in the new Bill
Read more >>

Southbanker Image

Southbanker

Bringing our river to life
Read more >>

Port Places

Fishermans Bend: the first quarter 2019
Read more >>

Housing Image

Housing

We are leaving an intergenerational time bomb for our children
Read more >>

History Image

History

Pubs in Southbank
Read more >>

Safety and Security

Winter vehicle and driving safety
Read more >>

Yarra River Business Association Image

Yarra River Business Association

A constantly changing market
Read more >>

Southbank Sustainability Group Image

Southbank Sustainability Group

Positive changes in our neighbourhood
Read more >>

Health and Wellbeing Image

Health and Wellbeing

Why your partner won’t measure up (and why that’s ok)
Read more >>

Skypad Living Image

Skypad Living

Vertical village parcel delivery
Read more >>

Pets Corner Image

Pets Corner

Dogs spreading happiness
Read more >>

Southbank Fashion Image

Southbank Fashion

Spring racing in Southbank
Read more >>

Street Smarts Image

Street Smarts

Power Street – Southbank
Read more >>

Letters Image

Letters

Tram shame
Read more >>

Owners corporation law

10 Apr 2016

How to restrict the potential for intimidation at meetings and on the common property

My colleagues in the United States that practice law in the field of Homeowners Associations (HOAs) are currently grappling with a big legal issue. And I’m very glad that here in Australia, we won’t have to deal with it.

A number of HOAs and condominium complexes are attempting to pass rules that would prohibit guns from being brought to meetings on common property.

Ordinarily, it would be a constitutional and inalienable right in the USA for persons to carry guns with them on common property, however recently the courts have held that HOAs can pass rules designed to “promote the health, happiness and peace of mind of the unit owners”.

The pro-gun community argue that carrying guns to meetings will ensure the happiness and peace of mind of owners, as they should feel secure and safe, while the anti-gun lobby argue that carrying guns to a meeting would provide no peace of mind to unit owners at all, and could lead to intimidation and the threat of violence in a setting where issues such as raising special levies, repairing building defects, terminating service providers and enforcing community rules need to be discussed and resolved.

A determination on this legal issue is pending in the US courts. For safety’s sake, I hope that a precedent can be established to restrict and prohibit guns at meetings. However, from a legal perspective, I foresee that the court would be duty bound to uphold the constitution and to declare that owners may carry their guns to protect their homes.

I’m certainly thankful that we live in a society where citizens carrying guns for protection is outlawed. As a lawyer, I’ve been to my fair share of hostile meetings, but fortunately I’ve never had to consider wearing a bulletproof vest to a meeting. Besides, it would look too bulky underneath my suit.

Jokes aside, there is a worrying pattern developing in Australia. I’ve now attended several meetings where security contractors have been present. I’ve broken up a fist fight that started between two owners over whether to repair building defects or sue the developer.

In Sydney in 2014, a strata manager was shot in the neck at a special general meeting. The shooter, a male elderly pensioner that was later found by the courts to be “mentally incompetent” had set out to kill the strata manager and to take his position. Apart from the gun, he was also carrying a long kitchen knife and several clips of ammunition.

A survey of strata managers found that more than 70 per cent reported feeling unsafe and intimidated at meetings within the last 12 months.

Certainly, it is not that I believe that one isolated incident of gun violence in Sydney could spark a trend of similar incidents. Indeed this could be the only incident involving a gun at an OC meeting in Australia’s history, and clearly not a cause for concern.

However, my concern is that the potential for faulty decisions to be made due to threats of violence or intimidation (with no guns present) at a strata meeting could have serious legal implications.

I have seen it happen time and again, and I should think that bringing in the secret ballot process as part of Consumer Affairs Victoria’s legislative reforms in this area would go a long way to addressing issues of intimidation on the common property.

Tom Bacon is the principal lawyer of Strata Title Lawyers.

Tom@stratatitlelawyers.com.au

Stay in touch with Southbank. Subscribe to FREE monthly e-Newspaper.

You must be registered with Southbank Local News to be able to post comments.
To register, please click here.