ad

Claims of ill-health protect Doyle

Claims of ill-health protect Doyle
Shane Scanlan

By claiming ill-health, Robert Doyle looks like walking away from allegations of sexual assault and misconduct with a damaged reputation, but with no formal legal finding against him.

The specific condition of the former lord mayor’s health has not been publicly revealed, but in April a Melbourne Health investigation by Charles Scerri QC was called off because Mr Doyle’s health prevented him from responding.

After allegations surfaced in December, Robert Doyle resigned his position as lord mayor. He also resigned as chairman of Melbourne Health around the same time.

In a statement about Mr Scerri’s “final report”, Melbourne Health said:

“Mr Scerri has no reason to doubt, and at present does not doubt, the veracity of the complainant;

However, because of ill health, Mr Doyle has been unable to respond to the allegations; and

In the absence of any response from Mr Doyle, Mr Scerri is not able to reach, and has not reached, any conclusions about the allegations.”

But Mr Doyle’s lawyer, Nick Ruskin, says his client was not sent details of the allegations.

“The investigation did not progress due to our client’s ill health. It did not progress to a stage where he was forwarded any material by the investigator,” Mr Ruskin said.

Mr Ruskin did not reply to Docklands News’s further questions about what is actually wrong with Mr Doyle.

“Is he terminally ill?  If not, why wouldn’t the investigators just wait until he was well again?” Southbank Local News asked.

Southbank Local News News asked Mr Scerri: “Did you decide alone to discontinue the investigation?  Or were you instructed by Melbourne Health (or someone in government) to terminate the inquiry?”

He replied: “It would not be appropriate for me to comment.”

A spokesperson for Health Minister Jill Hennessy would not make any on the record comments.

Mr Doyle’s claims of ill-health have also prevented a City of Melbourne inquiry by Dr Ian Freckelton QC from being concluded.

In March, council CEO Ben Rimmer released a summary of a report from Dr Freckleton in which he made four adverse findings against Mr Doyle.

Mr Rimmer appears to have little appetite to further pursue Mr Doyle to answer outstanding allegations from a so-called “third victim”.

The “third victim” is the woman Mr Doyle allegedly assaulted at a Melbourne Health awards presentation evening. Messrs Scerri and Freckelton were seeking Mr Doyle’s response over the same incident.

The woman Tweeted on April 26: “We can all thank MCC and Melbourne Health for setting a new precedent and a way of avoidance for perpetrators. Malka Leifer and Doyle shielded by mental illness. Where is the justice?”

She also wrote: “Acting CEO Ruth Vine and CEO Christine Kilpatrick of Melbourne Health heard of Robert Doyle’s inappropriate behaviour in Dec 2017 and did nothing other than suggest it is in best interests to remain silent. Charles Scerri finds Melb Health of no wrongdoing. How is this fair?”

A spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services said:

“We received advice from his legal advisors that Mr Doyle should not participate in the investigation nor read related materials.”

“Mr Doyle was written to five times and in each instance his lawyer stated that Mr Doyle was unable to participate.”

“Mr Doyle’s lawyers never sought an extension of time to allow Mr Doyle to participate in the investigation.”

“We would be pleased to offer Mr Doyle the further opportunity to attend an interview with Mr Scerri QC and respond to the allegations (a copy of which Mr Doyle has previously received).”

“If Mr Doyle becomes available for an interview, Mr Scerri QC will recommence the investigation.”

The spokesperson on April 27 amended this final paragraph to read “When Mr Doyle ...”

Following the woman speaking on 774 Melbourne radio on May 3, the department completed a further arc in its back flip when it said it had written to Mr Doyle requesting that he attend an interview within 10 days to respond to allegations, or undertake an independent medical assessment.

The ABC reported on and published photos of Mr Doyle outdoors at an Albert Park cafe with what appeared to be a glass of wine.

The woman told ABC presenter Jon Faine she was regretting making the complaint in the first place as she was assured it would lead to an outcome.

Join our Facebook Group
ad