A fresh start for Port Phillip Council

The 2024 City of Port Phillip election has delivered results that signal a significant shift in the council’s political landscape under the new single-member ward system. Voters have made their voices heard, calling for change, and the outcomes reflect this. 

Former mayor Heather Cunsolo stormed home in Port Melbourne Ward, claiming more than 65 per cent of the final vote, a commanding victory that reflects her strong community ties and a reputation for delivering.

In Montague Ward, Alex Makin emerged victorious in a tightly contested three-way race, leveraging his favourable ballot position and preferences from progressive networks. Meanwhile, in South Melbourne Ward, Beti Jay of Residents of Port Phillip (RoPP) overcame well-organised opponents, securing a win through grassroots campaigning and a clear focus on South Melbourne’s unique identity, with the help of an aligned running mate.

Councillors Cunsolo, Makin, and Jay each tapped into their local communities with targeted, meaningful platforms. Cr Cunsolo emphasised community engagement, Cr Makin stood out with pet-friendly policies, and Cr Jay brought attention to South Melbourne’s neglect by previous councils.

The big winners were independents and the RoPP, which now commands significant influence.

The ALP retained two seats, with Louise Crawford re-elected in Elwood Ward for a third term, and newcomer Libby Buckingham securing Balaclava Ward, but the party has otherwise lost ground.

The Greens, once a dominant force, now hold no seats, a dramatic fall from their peak of three councillors in 2016.

This new council composition brings with it both opportunities and challenges. RoPP’s three seats give them a strong mandate for change, while independents like Crs Cunsolo, Makin, and returning Serge Thomann will wield critical influence.

The election of Louise Crawford as mayor surprised some, as many anticipated a fresh start in leadership. Byran Mears, RoPP’s representative for Lakeside Ward, was named deputy mayor after a tightly contested vote.

Unity will be the key to success for this council, and early signs suggest a steady approach. However, campaign tensions and differing priorities could pose hurdles. Leadership and action will be essential to maintaining cohesion and delivering results.

My advice? Don’t let the grass grow under your feet. Fishermans Bend presents pressing funding and governance challenges, and decisive action is imperative. Encouragingly, I understand that City of Melbourne Lord Mayor Nick Reece has reached out to some Port Phillip councillors, offering collaboration on critical initiatives, including the extension of the M9 group and Fishermans Bend’s future.

The people of Port Phillip have demanded change. This council now has the opportunity, and the responsibility, to deliver.

The community will be watching closely. Results, not rhetoric, are what matter now. •

Marcus Pearl is a former mayor and councillor of the City of Port Phillip. During the 2024 Port Phillip election, he hosted @marcuspearltalks, a social media show providing insights and commentary on the campaigns, candidates, and issues shaping the election.